Surface Pro Pen Compatibility / Interoperability FAQ

Many customers seem confused about which Surface Pen features work on which Surface devices. The table below summarizes compatibility between different pen generations and Surface device models. Pressure sensitivity, latency, initial activation force, and tilt functionality are detailed as well using best available information as of 2017/07/31.

Disclaimer: This information is subject to change if/when Microsoft releases additional details; some assumptions about the implementation are based on n-Trig/Microsoft patent filings.

df4716a4079bb8a12c79ff306fc9aefd_preview_featured[1]

How to read the table:

  • 256, 1024, or 4096 indicates the number of pressure sensitivity levels available when using the pen and device model together. (256=8-bit, 1024=10-bit, 4096=12-bit.) In practice, many customers will not notice a difference in the pressure sensitivity given limited hand dexterity and the dynamic range compression/clamping side-effects of many software applications. The available pressure levels depends on a combination of the pen, digitizer hardware, and device drivers.
  • Tilt indicates that the Surface device has an accelerometer and the Pen incorporates some device enabling the Pen/Ink API to detect the angle of the pen with respect to the screen. According to n-Trig patent filings, this device could be an accelerometer, gyro, or a secondary radio emitter positioned such that the digitizer can infer the pen orientation. This allows software to change brush strokes on-the-fly based on the tilt of the pen. Even without the tilt feature, RF triangulation can enable the digitizer system to recognize gross orientation of the pen (right-handed use vs left-handed use for example) to optimize the tracking behavior. Assuming the user rests their palm on the screen, palm-rejection can also help optimize tracking behavior.
  • >21ms, >40ms, >55ms, >75ms, or >100ms indicates the minimum digitizer->screen latency. Real-world latency may be up to 50ms higher depending on the software being used, the refresh rate of the screen, and the timing of the pen event with respect to the refresh of the current frame. Assuming worst case at a 60Hz screen refresh rate, you can conservatively add 16.67ms (the time it takes to render one frame) to each of the quoted figures to get a more realistic latency. Device driver and software application updates can significantly alter the latency behavior making responsiveness better or worse.
  • 9g, 10g, 21g, 42g indicates the initial activation force (IAF) in grams which is the minimum amount of pressure applied to the tip of the pen to register as a stroke  on-screen. Less force is better for light strokes of the pen – but too little IAF can result in unwanted strokes. This is a crucial tuning factor for any pen/digitizer system. The ideal IAF is highly subjective depending on the artist. Typically Wacom designs have an IAF of 1-10 grams while n-Trig designs are on the order of 10-50 grams. With each generation of n-Trig pens, the IAF has decreased. To compare IAF across pen manufacturers, each pen design must be mounted and tested on the same test rig at a variety of angles since the response may be different in a vertical orientation compared to a natural writing angle depending on the mechanical implementation.
  • n/a indicates that the pen and device combination does not work.
Pen / Device   Pro1    Pro2    Pro3    3    Pro4    Book    Studio    Laptop    Pro2017 / Book2   Hub 
Ver.1 Wacom (SP1/SP2) 256
>100ms
~10g
1024
>100ms
~10g
n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a
Ver.2 n-Trig (SP3) n/a n/a 256
>75ms
~42g
256
>75ms
~42g
256
>40ms
~42g
256
>40ms
~42g
256
>40ms
~42g
256
>40ms
~42g
256
>21ms
~42g
n/a
Ver.3 n-Trig (SP4) n/a n/a 256
>75ms
~21g
256
>75ms
~21g
1024
>40ms
~21g
1024
>40ms
~21g
1024
>40ms
~21g
1024
>40ms
~21g
1024
>21ms
~21g
n/a
Ver.4 n-Trig (SP2017) n/a n/a 256
>75ms
9g
256
>75ms
9g
1024*
>40ms
tilt*
9g
1024*
>40ms
tilt*
9g
1024*
>40ms
tilt*
9g
1024
>40ms
9g
4096
>21ms
tilt
9g
n/a
PPI (SurfaceHub) n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a 1024 >55ms

*Ver.4 n-Trig tilt functionality and enhanced pressure sensitivity may be enabled on some older Surface models via driver/firmware updates in early 2018.

Which pens shipped with which device models?

  • Wacom Ver.1 pens shipped with the Surface Pro 1 and Surface Pro 2.
  • n-Trig Ver.2 pens shipped with the Surface Pro 3 and was an optional accessory for the Surface 3.
  • n-Trig Ver.3 pens shipped with the Surface Book, Surface Studio and Surface Pro 4 (except m3 model). It is an optional accessory for other models.
  • n-Trig Ver.4 pens are optional accessories designed for the 2017 Surface Pro but also work on other models.
  • Two Surface Hub pens based on the Perceptive Pixel (PPI) digitizer technology are shipped with each Surface Hub.

Replaceable pen tips?

  • n-Trig Ver.2 pens has a replaceable tip. Replacement tips are available and may be swapped from other pen manufacturers.
  • n-Trig Ver.3/Ver.4 pens use the same swappable tips. Microsoft sells a 4-pack of tips each with a different writing feel.

Batteries?

  • Wacom Ver.1 pens use electromagnetic digitizers and need no batteries.
  • n-Trig Ver.2 pens are powered by a AAAA battery combined with two #319 (SR527SW) button cells.
  • n-Trig Ver.3/Ver.4 pens are powered by a single AAAA battery.
  • Surface Hub pens have non-replaceable rechargeable batteries and charge when docked on the Hub.

Buttons?

  • Wacom Ver.1 pens have 2 buttons
  • n-Trig Ver.2 pens have 3 buttons
  • n-Trig Ver.3/Ver.4 pens have 2 buttons plus “eraser”
  • Surface Hub pens have an “eraser” but no buttons

Clip?

Swapping top and bottom half between pens? Can I just get a new top half?

  • Some folks like to re-use parts from a broken pen and mix and match colors. For example a Blue bottom and sliver top. You can freely mix and match colors within the same generation of pen. Unfortunately, it is not possible to order half a pen from Microsoft.
  • Ver.2, Ver.3, and Ver.4 top and bottom halves are not designed to be interchangeable. Ver.2 has a screw-on top while Ver.3 and Ver.4 have slightly different spring tab configurations. The sizing and fastening is slightly different between Ver.3 and Ver.4 so even if you can get it to fit, you may ruin the internal tab that holds the two halves together.

References:

Did I miss anything? Please comment and I’ll add it to the article.

Edit: Changed Gen0-Gen3 terminology to Ver.1-Ver.4 to be consistent with Microsoft documentation

Back to https://dancharblog.wordpress.com &nbsp

Advertisements

9 thoughts on “Surface Pro Pen Compatibility / Interoperability FAQ

Add yours

  1. Despite what the patent says, there are no accelerometers or gyroscopes in any tilt-sensing pen technology (Apple, Wacom EMR, Microsoft). Apple uses additional sensors that are perpendicular to the tip of the pen and analyzes the shape of the signal on the digitizer. Wacom EMR analyzes the shape of the signal on the digitizer without any additional emitters. Microsoft (according to the patent) added more emitters to create an asymmetrical signal on the digitizer, which then lets it calculate 3D orientation. Not a single one uses accelerometers or gyroscopes.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thanks Jack. I misread the filing. I’ve updated the post accordingly to indicate n-Trig may be using one or more of these techniques. A secondary emitter makes a lot more sense given power consumption of an accelerometer/gyro package.

      Like

  2. So there’s no current evidence that the surface studio nor surface book performance base will be capable of the lowest latency features?

    Like

  3. I just purchased a new surface pro having never had one before. The new pen seems a bit steep (im not an artist, just want a pen) so want to buy and old version of surface pen . Some information says the old pens are compatible with the new pro and other websites don’t. Any chance you can clarity?

    Like

    1. Sarah, the Surface Pro 4 pen (aka Ver.3) will work fine on your Surface Pro 2017. Can you please point out the websites you found which claim the older pen does not work?

      Like

  4. So the latency depends on the digitizer layer on the screen of the Surface Pro/Book Etc. itself not the Pen. Interesting. I thought it was the pen in conjunction with the Surface device initially.

    Like

  5. I just had to upgrade from the first generation surface pro to the newest surface pro tablet. I keep reading that any pen should work like finger point touch in Microsoft 365 apps, but my old SP1 pen won’t work on newSP. Am I mistaken??
    Thanks!

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Create a website or blog at WordPress.com

Up ↑

%d bloggers like this: